Talk:Rodger

Copy of entry I made at Wiktionary:Beer_parlour

Can we kill with kindness - Wiktionary that is

I'm feeling that maybe people can add too much to Wiktionary, and end up killing it with just too much content. Adding Rodger was a mistake of mine. I was not adding it as a personal name, I was adding it for a specific meaning. When someone pointed out that there was already an entry for this meaning under Roger I deleted the Rodger page content. But Paul G added it back as just simply a Personal Name. Does that mean we have every single known first name as an entry in the Wiktionary ? My vote is NO. Especially in this day and age when people invent given names. I'm even worried by someone adding pages such as Wiktionary Appendix:Surnames begin with m. But I think it would be better to have a pageWiktionary Appendix:Personal names beginning with R, and only having Rodger in that list, not as an entry.--Richardb 01:56, 21 Nov 2004 (UTC)