Reconstruction talk:Proto-Samoyedic/ërö

From Wiktionary, the free dictionary
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Regarding supposed Nganasan, Enets, and Forest Nenets descendants

[edit]
Latest comment: 8 days ago1 comment1 person in discussion

I've decided to remove the aforementioned entries that are listed under Janhunen (1977)'s reconstruction, since I've looked over the materials for each of the respective languages and I have found no words that match.

Each of the languages' words for ‘fall/autumn’ (as well as ‘year’) are clearly unrelated to PSam *ërö ~ *ërǝjǝj:

  • Nganasan: (fall/autumn) ӈитү/ӈүтү, ӈитүо/ӈүтүо; (year) хүо
  • Enets: (fall/autumn) F ɔtuz, T [not found]; (year) F pɔ, T pɔa
  • Forest Nenets: (fall/autumn) мыԓичу; (year) по

Furthermore, Aikio (2020)'s draft of Proto-Uralic does not include any of these languages under *e̮δi[1] (using his notation).

  1. ^ Ante Aikio (2020) Uralic Etymological Dictionary (draft version of entries A–Ć; 1/17/2020)‎[1], page 49

Kulinkuu (talk) 15:49, 15 November 2024 (UTC)Reply

Retrieved from "https://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Reconstruction_talk:Proto-Samoyedic/ërö&oldid=82648498"