User talk:LoutK

From Wiktionary, the free dictionary
Latest comment: 2 years ago by LoutK in topic Hello!
Jump to navigation Jump to search
πŸ—„

Hello!

[edit]

Thanks for the message you left for me! I found it quite useful as I haven't quite got a hang of it (yet). I will (probably) mostly make/edit korean verb/adjective pages!

Also I'm a bit curious to why did you delete the "Also attested in Worin Seokbo" part of the μ—¬λ¬Όλ‹€ page (I referenced everything from ν‘œμ€€κ΅­μ–΄λŒ€μ‚¬μ „ except for the translation, which i did it myself) ν™μ‹œμ› (talk) 20:10, 2 March 2022 (UTC)Reply

@ν™μ‹œμ›: ν‘œμ€€κ΅­μ–΄λŒ€μ‚¬μ „ often doesn't make the distinction between older forms that are the direct ancestor of the modern form and older forms that are etymologically related to the modern form but aren't the direct ancestor. In the case of μ—¬λ¬Όλ‹€, MK μ—¬λ―ˆλ‹€ is clearly and uncontroversially the direct ancestor of the modern form.
Actually, for etymologies, you're better off using κ³ λ €λŒ€ν•œκ΅­μ–΄λŒ€μ‚¬μ „ (Naver and Daum host it) which does make this distinction and is, in my opinion, a better dictionary overall. I rarely consult ν‘œμ€€κ΅­μ–΄λŒ€μ‚¬μ „ except for pronunciation.
Anyways, I'd be really glad if you do continue creating these pages. We still have many Korean verb/adjective entries that are either missing or in need of a revamp. β€” LoutK (talk) 22:21, 2 March 2022 (UTC)Reply
Ah, I see. Thanks for the information! ν™μ‹œμ› (talk) 22:26, 2 March 2022 (UTC)Reply
@ν™μ‹œμ›: If you want to use ν‘œμ€€κ΅­μ–΄λŒ€μ‚¬μ „, look for the form that is directly next to the "<" sign. It is supposed to mark the ancestral form, and the slash is supposed to mark a related form that had co-existed with that form. The way that they haven't marked this clearly seems to have misled many. I would still consult μš°λ¦¬λ§μƒ˜ or κ³ λ €λŒ€ν•œκ΅­μ–΄λŒ€μ‚¬μ „ though, as ν‘œμ€€κ΅­μ–΄λŒ€μ‚¬μ „ hasn't been updated and often contradicts even its own μš°λ¦¬λ§μƒ˜ (like how it still lists οΌœμ‚¬α„…α†žλ‹€ for 살리닀 when μš°λ¦¬λ§μƒ˜ and κ³ λ €λŒ€ν•œκ΅­μ–΄λŒ€μ‚¬μ „ clearly state that it's not a direct ancestor). β€” LoutK (talk) 01:36, 3 March 2022 (UTC)Reply